Butter Gloss

NYX Butter Gloss is worth buying for most people who want an easy, inexpensive lip gloss. At $5.00, with a 4.3/5 rating from 19,800 reviews, it gets a lot right: comfortable feel, flattering sheer color, and a price that makes repeat purchases painless. My one real hesitation is that there is no ingredient list available in the data here, and as a dermatologist, I don't love that.

Is NYX Butter Gloss worth it?

Yes, for most shoppers, NYX Butter Gloss is a good buy. It's a drugstore lip gloss that promises a non-sticky, buttery texture with sheer coverage, and that is exactly the lane it stays in. If you want intense pigment or a long-wear formula, I'd skip it. If you want a soft, simple gloss you can throw on without thinking, this makes sense.

What is NYX Butter Gloss?

NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss is a lip gloss in the drugstore price tier. The brand positions itself as professional-quality makeup at drugstore prices, which is an ambitious claim, but honestly, this product is one of the better examples of that idea actually working.

The official description is straightforward: a buttery soft, silky smooth lip gloss in a wide range of shades. The brand claims three main things:

1. Non-sticky feel n2. Buttery texture
2. Sheer coverage

That combination tells you exactly who this is for. Butter Gloss is best for someone who likes gloss but hates that heavy, gluey feeling some formulas leave behind. It also suits people who want color that looks forgiving. Sheer glosses are easier to apply than opaque liquid lip products, and they fade more gracefully.

NYX says it's suitable for all skin types, which is fair enough for a lip product. Skin type matters less here than lip condition. If your lips are very dry or cracked, gloss can make them look shinier, but it won't necessarily fix the dryness underneath.

One more thing that matters to a lot of shoppers: NYX is listed here as cruelty-free: true and clean: false. I don't put much stock in the word "clean" because it's poorly regulated and often more marketing than science. Cruelty-free, though, is a concrete point if that affects your buying decisions.

What’s actually in NYX Butter Gloss?

Here's the honest answer: the ingredient list is not available in the data provided. I have mixed feelings about that, and I don't want to pretend otherwise.

As a reviewer, I can talk about texture claims, finish, price, and how a gloss like this usually behaves. As a dermatologist, I want the actual INCI list before making strong statements about irritants, allergens, fragrance, or acne-triggering ingredients around the mouth. Since that information isn't here, any ingredient-specific analysis would be guesswork.

What we can say from the available data

Based on the product claims, NYX Butter Gloss is designed to feel:

• Buttery
• Silky smooth
• Non-sticky
• Sheer rather than fully opaque

That usually points to a formula built around emollients and glossing agents rather than high wax content. It likely prioritizes slip and shine over long wear. That's common for lip gloss, and it's part of why these formulas tend to feel comfortable at first but need reapplication.

Safety notes and irritation concerns

Since the ingredient list isn't available, there are a few things I can't verify:

• Whether it contains fragrance or flavoring agents
• Whether it includes common sensitizers
• Whether it has lanolin, certain oils, or dyes that might bother very reactive skin
• Whether there are ingredients some users consider comedogenic around the lip line

Look, lip products can absolutely trigger irritation in people with eczema, perioral dermatitis, or fragrance sensitivity. Even a product marketed as soft and silky can cause issues if you're prone to reactions. Without the ingredient list, I can't confidently tell you how low-risk this is for sensitive users.

Is NYX Butter Gloss comedogenic?

Unclear. There is no ingredient data available, so I can't assess comedogenic risk ingredient by ingredient. In practice, lip gloss is most likely to cause minor breakouts or clogged pores around the mouth, especially if it migrates beyond the lip border or if you tend to touch that area a lot.

If you're acne-prone around the chin or upper lip, here's my practical advice:

1. Keep the gloss mostly on the lips, not the surrounding skin.
2. Remove it fully at the end of the day.
3. Patch test if you've reacted to lip products before.

That's not dramatic advice, but it's the safest route when ingredient transparency is limited.

How does NYX Butter Gloss perform?

This is where NYX Butter Gloss makes its case. The formula's whole identity is comfort, and that tends to be why people keep repurchasing it.

Texture and feel

The texture is meant to be buttery and non-sticky, and that tracks with the product's reputation and review profile. A 4.3/5 rating across 19,800 reviews is strong for a $5 gloss, especially in a category where people are very quick to complain if something feels tacky or messy.

Gloss is always a balancing act. If it's too thin, it disappears in 20 minutes. If it's too thick, your hair gets stuck in it and you regret your life choices the second you step outside. Butter Gloss seems to sit in the middle. That's a good place to be.

I keep coming back to the fact that NYX didn't overpromise here. It says sheer coverage, not vinyl-level shine and eight-hour wear. That's realistic. A comfortable gloss should feel smooth, add shine, and give a wash of color. It doesn't need to pretend it's a liquid lipstick.

Absorption and wear over time

Lip gloss doesn't absorb the way skincare does, but it does settle and wear down over a few hours. With a formula described as buttery and sheer, I'd expect this pattern over 2 to 4 weeks of regular use:

1. First few wears: It feels soft and easy, with enough cushion to make lips look smoother.
2. After a week or two: You'll probably notice whether the non-sticky claim works for you personally. Most people who like this product seem to think it does, but "non-sticky" is always relative.
3. By weeks 2 to 4: The strengths and weaknesses become obvious. It's convenient, flattering, and easy to reapply. It probably won't last through meals, and you'll need touch-ups through the day.

Honestly, that's fine. At $5.00, I don't expect luxury wear time. I expect decent comfort and color payoff that doesn't look patchy. This kind of gloss is best judged by how often you actually reach for it, and the huge review count suggests a lot of people do.

Coverage and finish

NYX says this has sheer coverage, which I think is a smart choice for a widely appealing gloss. Sheer products are forgiving on dry lips and easier to wear without a mirror. They also make a broad shade range more usable, since the color is less intimidating on the lips than it may look in the tube.

That said, sheer coverage can disappoint people who want stronger pigment. If you're expecting a bold, opaque gloss, this probably won't satisfy you. The word "Butter" can make a formula sound richer or more substantial than it actually is. Here, it seems to refer more to feel than to color impact.

Does it actually feel non-sticky?

Probably more non-sticky than average, yes. Completely non-sticky? I doubt it. Most gloss formulas have at least some tack because that's part of what helps them adhere to the lips. I get skeptical whenever any gloss claims zero stickiness.

So my take is this: NYX Butter Gloss is likely less sticky than many drugstore glosses, but if you hate every trace of gloss texture, you'll still know you're wearing it.

NYX Butter Gloss price and value

This is one of the easiest parts of the review. NYX Butter Gloss costs $5.00 at most major retailers in the data provided.

Current prices

• CVS: $5.00 (in stock)
• Target: $5.00 (in stock)
• Ulta: $5.00 (in stock)
• Walmart: $5.00 (in stock)
• Amazon: $5.02 (in stock)

Where is it cheapest?

The cheapest price right now is $5.00, tied at CVS, Target, Ulta, and Walmart. Amazon is slightly higher at $5.02, which is basically negligible, but still, if we're being exact, it's not the best deal.

Is the value good?

Yes. For five dollars, you are getting a product with nearly 20,000 reviews and a 4.3-star average, which is better than a lot of trendier glosses that cost three or four times as much. I like expensive makeup as much as anyone, but lip gloss is one category where drugstore formulas often get very close.

The one thing that weakens the value case for me is the missing ingredient information in the provided data. If you have sensitive lips, ingredient transparency matters. If you don't have a history of irritation and you just want a cute, comfortable gloss, the value is hard to argue with.

Price per ounce comparison

I can't calculate price per ounce because the product size isn't included in the data. That's frustrating, because it's one of the best ways to compare value across gloss formulas. So I won't fake precision here. Based on sticker price alone, though, Butter Gloss is clearly on the affordable end of the market.

Pros and cons

Here's the blunt version.

Pros

• Very affordable at $5.00
• Strong consumer reception, with a 4.3/5 rating from 19,800 reviews
• Sheer coverage is easy to wear and forgiving
• Buttery, silky concept appeals to people who dislike thick gloss
• Widely available at CVS, Target, Ulta, Walmart, and Amazon
• Cruelty-free brand status is a plus for many shoppers
• Drugstore pricing makes it easy to buy more than one shade

Cons

• No ingredient list available in the provided data, which is a real drawback
• Sheer coverage may feel too subtle if you want bold color
• "Non-sticky" is probably true only relative to other glosses, not in an absolute sense
• Gloss format means reapplication is almost certainly necessary through the day
• Amazon is slightly more expensive at $5.02 than the other listed retailers
• "Clean" is listed as false, which may matter to shoppers who prioritize that label

Who should buy NYX Butter Gloss?

NYX Butter Gloss makes the most sense for a few specific people.

Buy it if you want:

• A budget-friendly lip gloss under $10
• Sheer, easy color rather than full opacity
• A softer, smoother feel than old-school sticky glosses
• A low-risk makeup purchase with lots of social proof
• A cruelty-free drugstore option

I especially like this for younger makeup users, casual gloss wearers, and anyone rebuilding a makeup bag without spending much. It's also a nice desk, purse, or car gloss because replacing a $5 product hurts a lot less than replacing a $24 one.

Who should skip NYX Butter Gloss?

Some people should probably pass.

Skip it if you want:

• Full-pigment gloss with strong color payoff
• Long wear through meals and drinks
• Complete ingredient transparency before buying
• A gloss with confirmed suitability for very sensitive lips

If you've had allergic reactions to lip products before, I would be cautious here until you can verify the full ingredient list directly from the brand or retailer packaging. That's the most responsible answer.

My final call on NYX Butter Gloss

I think NYX Butter Gloss is worth buying if your expectations are realistic. It's a $5.00 drugstore lip gloss with a 4.3/5 rating from 19,800 reviews, and those numbers suggest consistent satisfaction, not just hype. The appeal is simple: soft feel, easy shine, wearable color.

My reservation is the lack of ingredient data in the information provided. That won't matter to everyone, but it does matter to me, especially for people with sensitive lips or a history of irritation around the mouth.

So here's my specific recommendation: buy NYX Butter Gloss from CVS, Target, Ulta, or Walmart for $5.00, skip Amazon unless it's more convenient, and choose it if you want a comfortable, sheer everyday gloss. If you need opaque color or you react easily to lip products, hold off until you can check the full ingredient list first.

FAQs

Is NYX Butter Gloss worth the price?

Yes. At $5.00, NYX Butter Gloss is reasonably priced and backed by a 4.3/5 rating from 19,800 reviews. That combination makes it one of the safer drugstore gloss bets if you want comfort and sheer shine more than dramatic wear time.

What are the key ingredients in NYX Butter Gloss?

I can't verify the key ingredients because no ingredient list is available in the data provided. That means I can't responsibly assess fragrance, common irritants, or comedogenic ingredients. If you have sensitive lips, check the packaging or the brand's official listing before buying.

Is NYX Butter Gloss actually non-sticky?

Probably less sticky than many traditional glosses, yes. Completely non-sticky, I wouldn't promise that. Most glosses have some tack, and this one likely does too, just in a softer, more comfortable way.

How much coverage does NYX Butter Gloss give?

The brand claims sheer coverage, so expect a wash of color rather than opaque pigment. That's great if you want something easy and flattering. It's less ideal if you want a bold gloss look.

Where can you buy NYX Butter Gloss for the lowest price?

Right now, CVS, Target, Ulta, and Walmart all have it for $5.00, while Amazon lists it at $5.02. The difference is tiny, but the cheapest option in the current data is still the $5.00 listings.