Clinique Black Honey Dupes: 6 Cheaper Alternatives That Work

Start here

The verdict

I'd start with e.l.f. Sheer Slick Lipstick in Black Cherry for a cheaper version of Black Honey's sheer, shiny lip effect. Burt's Bees Red Dahlia is my US budget choice if a softer tint is enough. Clinique currently costs $25 for 1.9 g; the e.l.f. tube costs $6 for the same stated weight. I would buy one promising alternative before spending more on a basket of near-matches.

Closest matche.l.f. Sheer Slick Lipstick in Black Cherry$6.00 · 0.06 oz / 1.9 g

A sheer, shiny lipstick format with published comparative swatches and a $19 upfront saving.

Read the comparison ↓
Best budget pickBurt's Bees Tinted Lip Balm in Red Dahlia$4.99 · 0.15 oz / 4.25 g

The $4.99 US price is the lowest checked here; choose it for a restrained tint rather than maximum shade depth.

Read the comparison ↓

Save up to 80%the original is $25.00 — the dupes here start at $4.99

The caveat. These are alternatives in shade and finish. None is established as an identical formula, and the current UK Nivea version has not been directly matched.

Clinique Almost Lipstick in Black Honey
In 20 seconds

Key takeaways

  • My closest starting point is e.l.f. Sheer Slick in Black Cherry: $6 for 1.9 g, versus Clinique's $25 for 1.9 g.
  • Burt's Bees Red Dahlia is the lowest-priced US pick at $4.99; it suits a subtler tint.
  • Ecstatic leans cooler; Ember is a deep-mauve alternative with only a $3 upfront saving.
  • Nivea's current UK 72h Blackberry Shine is £3; older US swatches do not verify this formula.
The numbers

At a glance

ProductPriceSizePrice/ozRole
Clinique Almost Lipstick in Black Honey$25.000.06 oz / 1.9 g$416.67/ozOriginal
e.l.f. Sheer Slick Lipstick in Black Cherry$6.000.06 oz / 1.9 g$100.00/ozMy closest overall pick
e.l.f. Hydrating Core Lip Shine in Ecstatic$8.000.09 oz$88.89/ozFor a cooler berry tint
CoverGirl Clean Fresh Tinted Lip Balm in Bliss You Berry$7.990.14 oz$57.07/ozAnother sheer berry option
Burt's Bees Tinted Lip Balm in Red Dahlia$4.990.15 oz / 4.25 g$33.27/ozLowest-priced US pick
Nivea 72h Blackberry Shine Lip Balm£3.004.8 g—Low-cost UK berry option
Glossier Ultralip in Ember$22.000.10 oz / 3 g$220.00/ozFor a deeper mauve direction

Prices and sizes checked November 14, 2026.

Black Friday is live: the beauty deals worth it, and dupes that save up to $435.

Trust, but verify

How we compared

I compared exact shade names, current brand or retailer listings, package sizes and published swatches. A Beauty Edit provides first-person comparative swatches for several options; those are the original tester's observations, not an Insider Beauty wear trial. Matching evidence is moderate where those comparisons support the choice and weak where only the current product description supports a colour-family alternative. No ingredient list here establishes formula equivalence.

Prices were checked on 14 November 2026. US figures exclude tax and delivery; Nivea is a separate UK £3 listing. Price per ounce uses the rounded ounce quantity printed on the pack, so it is an approximate comparison. It does not estimate cost per application.

For your own shade check, compare clean lips in the same daylight, with similar coverage and no different liners underneath. Check the result after a light application and again at the intensity you actually wear. A match on an arm or a different person's lips is useful evidence, but not a promise of a match on yours.

Closest match
Sheer Slick Lipstick — Black Cherry
My closest overall pick

e.l.f. Sheer Slick Lipstick in Black Cherry

$6.000.06 oz / 1.9 g$100.00/oz

I'd buy Black Cherry first if the aim is a cheaper version of Black Honey's sheer, polished lip effect. At $6 for 1.9 g, it is $19 less upfront than Clinique's $25, 1.9 g tube. That is a meaningful saving without buying a larger pack or relying on a sale.

The balmy, buildable format is the attraction. e.l.f. describes a sheer wash of colour with shine, which is the right kind of product to compare with Almost Lipstick. Sarah Roberts' published swatch comparison also places Black Cherry as her favourite Black Honey alternative. That supports putting it first, but it does not establish identical colour or wear on every lip.

Start with a light application and judge the colour before building. If what you specifically love about Clinique is the balance of brown, red and berry over your own lip colour, a small undertone difference may matter more than the saving. I'd still try this before buying several different balms in search of a match.

What matches

  • Sheer, buildable colour in a balmy lipstick format
  • A shiny finish rather than an opaque matte lip

What doesn't

  • A different finished formula; an exact colour match is not established
  • The $6 price is for Black Cherry, not every similarly named e.l.f. lip product

Pick it if You want the closest starting point here without spending much.

The catch. A side-by-side comparison on your lips still matters if Black Honey is an exact favourite.

Where to buye.l.f.US
Find on AmazonAmazon opens the store for your country, where available.

Evidence: moderate (https://www.elfcosmetics.com/products/sheer-slick-lipstick-black-cherry-black-cherry, https://www.abeautyedit.com/clinique-black-honey-dupes/).

Hydrating Core Lip Shine — Ecstatic
For a cooler berry tint

e.l.f. Hydrating Core Lip Shine in Ecstatic

$8.000.09 oz$88.89/oz

Ecstatic is the one I'd consider if Black Honey appeals but you would prefer the colour to lean further toward purple. The comparative swatches from A Beauty Edit identify that cooler difference. It is more useful to know that before buying than to be told both tubes are simply “berry.”

The current price is $8 for 0.09 oz, saving $17 against Clinique upfront. It costs $2 more than Sheer Slick Black Cherry, so I would choose it for the colour direction and the heart-core balm format rather than calling it the cheapest match.

e.l.f.'s own shade description is deep berry. Check that the selected shade is Ecstatic before checkout: the product page also offers other colours, and its default photograph may show another shade. A different colour in the same range is not the same recommendation.

The moisturizing core is a product feature, not evidence that it repairs lips better than Clinique. The decision here is the tint you want and the feel you prefer from a balm-style application.

What matches

  • A sheer berry tint with soft shine
  • A balm-style application that can be built gradually

What doesn't

  • Ecstatic is described in the comparative swatches as more purple than Black Honey
  • Its heart-shaped core and outer colour are a different product design

Pick it if You prefer a cooler berry direction and a balm-style product.

The catch. More purple is a reason to choose it, or a reason it will miss your ideal Black Honey colour.

Where to buye.l.f.US
Find on AmazonAmazon opens the store for your country, where available.

Evidence: moderate (https://www.elfcosmetics.com/products/hydrating-core-lip-shine, https://www.abeautyedit.com/clinique-black-honey-dupes/).

Clean Fresh Tinted Lip Balm — Bliss You Berry
Another sheer berry option

CoverGirl Clean Fresh Tinted Lip Balm in Bliss You Berry

$7.990.14 oz$57.07/oz

Bliss You Berry costs $7.99 for 0.14 oz at the checked Ulta listing. That is $17.01 below Clinique and a larger labelled weight. I'd consider it for someone who wants an everyday berry tint and values a straightforward drugstore purchase more than an exact Black Honey match.

The exact product matters. Look for Clean Fresh Tinted Lip Balm in Bliss You Berry. Similar packaging or a separate SPF version should not be treated as interchangeable with this listing. Check the shade name in the basket, not just the colour of the cap.

I would put it behind Sheer Slick for a buyer whose priority is reproducing Black Honey as closely as possible. The current product information supports a tinted balm in the right colour family; it does not establish matching undertones, transfer or wear. That distinction keeps a useful inexpensive alternative from becoming an unsupported clone claim.

If you already own it, compare a thin application before adding more. Additional layers change intensity and can make a comparison with one light swipe of Clinique misleading.

What matches

  • A tinted lip-balm format
  • A berry shade intended for a soft wash of colour

What doesn't

  • A cheaper berry balm is not evidence of an identical undertone
  • Do not confuse this with a separate SPF lip-balm listing

Pick it if You want a widely sold berry balm and can verify the exact shade.

The catch. The case for it is the format and price, not a demonstrated formula or wear match.

Where to buyUltaUS
Find on AmazonAmazon opens the store for your country, where available.

Evidence: weak (https://www.ulta.com/p/clean-fresh-tinted-lip-balm-pimprod2029982?sku=2591300).

Best budget pick
Tinted Lip Balm — Red Dahlia
Lowest-priced US pick

Burt's Bees Tinted Lip Balm in Red Dahlia

$4.990.15 oz / 4.25 g$33.27/oz

Red Dahlia is my budget pick for US shoppers at $4.99 for 4.25 g. It saves $20.01 against the checked Clinique price. That recommendation is about a low-cost, wearable tint, not a claim that the cheapest balm is also the closest colour match.

The comparative swatches describe this as the sheerest option in that tester's selection. I'd therefore choose it for someone who finds a built-up berry lip too strong, or who mainly wants a small amount of colour from a balm. If you want the depth of several layers of Black Honey, this is a less direct substitution than Sheer Slick.

The current listing describes a warm, deep-red tint. That is a useful reminder that “berry” covers several undertones. Your natural lip colour remains visible through a sheer product, so an arm swatch and a lip application answer different questions.

Do not confuse a moisturizing-duration claim with a promise that the colour lasts that long. I would buy Red Dahlia for its price and restrained colour, not an assumed all-day stain.

What matches

  • A sheer red-berry tint in a balm format
  • An easy route to a lighter everyday lip colour

What doesn't

  • Published comparative swatches describe it as particularly sheer
  • A subtle tint does not reproduce every built-up Black Honey look

Pick it if You want the lowest-priced US option and prefer a quiet tint.

The catch. Choose it for subtle colour; do not expect the same depth from the same number of passes.

Where to buyTargetUS
Find on AmazonAmazon opens the store for your country, where available.

Evidence: moderate (https://www.target.com/p/-/A-92045155, https://www.abeautyedit.com/clinique-black-honey-dupes/).

Low-cost UK berry option

Nivea 72h Blackberry Shine Lip Balm

£3.004.8 g

The current UK option checked here is Nivea 72h Blackberry Shine, 4.8 g, listed at Tesco for £3 before any loyalty promotion. I would consider it a low-cost way to try a berry-tinted balm. I would not convert that UK price into a supposed US bargain or attach an unverified US selling price to it.

The version distinction is important. Older Black Honey comparisons discuss Nivea Blackberry Lip Care. They are not proof that this current UK 72h Blackberry Shine has the same formula, pigment balance or finish. Its place on this page is as an affordable colour-family alternative, with weaker matching evidence than the first two e.l.f. choices.

The listing describes a blackberry-scented balm with buildable colour. If you dislike scented lip products, that may decide the purchase before shade similarity does. The “72h” wording belongs to the product name and its care claim; it is not a promise of three days of visible lip colour.

Check the pack and name against the linked retailer when ordering. A multipack or imported US version is a separate price and product comparison.

What matches

  • A buildable berry tint in a lip-balm format
  • An inexpensive UK route to trying this colour family

What doesn't

  • The current UK 72h product is not established as identical to older Blackberry Lip Care formulas
  • No direct comparison of this exact current version with Black Honey was verified

Pick it if You shop in the UK and want a £3 berry balm rather than an exact shade replica.

The catch. Older US Blackberry Lip Care swatches do not prove how this current UK formula matches.

Where to buyTescoUK
Find on AmazonAmazon opens the store for your country, where available.

Evidence: weak (https://www.tesco.com/shop/en-GB/products/330748761).

Ultra Lip — Ember
For a deeper mauve direction

Glossier Ultralip in Ember

$22.000.10 oz / 3 g$220.00/oz

Ember is the least persuasive money-saving recommendation here. At $22 for 3 g, it is only $3 cheaper to buy than Clinique's $25 tube. The larger quantity improves the price per gram, but that matters only if you use it; it does not reduce the amount charged at checkout.

Glossier describes Ember as deep mauve and Ultralip as a buildable lip colour combining balm and gloss qualities. I'd choose it because that shade and format appeal, not because every dark-looking sheer lipstick is interchangeable with Black Honey.

There is no verified side-by-side comparison in this research establishing an exact Ember match to Clinique. I would therefore keep it as an alternative colour direction rather than recommend it to someone replacing a precise favourite shade.

If saving money is the priority, Sheer Slick's $6 price leaves much more room. If you already like Ultralip and want a deeper mauve in that formula, Ember has its own reason to be considered. That is a stronger purchase rationale than buying it solely because it appears on a dupe list.

What matches

  • Buildable colour with a balm-and-gloss-style finish
  • A deeper shade that can be applied lightly

What doesn't

  • Glossier describes Ember as deep mauve, not a verified Black Honey shade match
  • The upfront saving is only $3

Pick it if You specifically prefer Ember and the Ultralip format.

The catch. It is a weak budget substitution if saving money is the main reason to switch.

Where to buyGlossierUS
Find on AmazonAmazon opens the store for your country, where available.

Evidence: weak (https://www.glossier.com/products/ultralip).

Save your money

Called a dupe, but isn't

An opaque berry lipstick

A dark berry colour in the tube does not establish the same result. Black Honey is sheer, allowing the underlying lip colour to show. An opaque lipstick in a similar family can cover that colour and give a different depth, edge and finish. Compare the applied result, not the bullet.

A different formula carrying the Black Honey name

The shade name alone does not make another lip formula equivalent to Almost Lipstick. Check that a comparison refers to the original sheer Almost Lipstick rather than a gloss, oil or other format. This guide prices the 1.9 g Almost Lipstick tube.

Still deciding?

FAQs

What is the closest cheaper alternative to Clinique Black Honey?

I'd start with e.l.f. Sheer Slick Lipstick in Black Cherry. Its sheer, shiny format and published comparative swatches make it the strongest starting point here at $6. It is not established as an identical formula or a perfect match on every lip.

Which Black Honey alternative costs the least in the US?

Burt's Bees Tinted Lip Balm in Red Dahlia was $4.99 for 4.25 g at the checked Target listing. It is a subtler tint, so lowest price does not mean closest shade depth.

Is e.l.f. Ecstatic the same colour as Black Honey?

Not exactly. The published comparative swatches describe Ecstatic as more purple. Choose it if that cooler direction appeals, rather than expecting an identical undertone.

Is Nivea Blackberry Shine the same product used in older dupe comparisons?

Do not assume so. This guide links the current UK 72h Blackberry Shine, 4.8 g. Older comparisons of US Blackberry Lip Care do not establish a match for that exact current UK version.

Does Glossier Ember save much money?

Only $3 upfront at the checked prices: $22 for 3 g versus $25 for 1.9 g of Clinique. Its larger quantity is useful if you prefer and use it, but it is not the strongest choice for a lower checkout total.

Why does the same sheer lipstick look different on different people?

Your natural lip colour shows through a sheer formula, and the amount applied changes the result. Lighting and any liner underneath also affect the comparison. Match the coverage and conditions before judging two shades.

Sources
  • https://www.clinique.com/products/almost-lipstick-in-black-honey-pink-honey-and-nude-honey
  • https://www.elfcosmetics.com/products/sheer-slick-lipstick-black-cherry-black-cherry
  • https://www.elfcosmetics.com/products/hydrating-core-lip-shine
  • https://www.ulta.com/p/clean-fresh-tinted-lip-balm-pimprod2029982?sku=2591300
  • https://www.target.com/p/-/A-92045155
  • https://www.tesco.com/shop/en-GB/products/330748761
  • https://www.glossier.com/products/ultralip
  • https://www.abeautyedit.com/clinique-black-honey-dupes/
Keep hunting

More dupe guides

Insider Beauty may earn a commission on purchases made through links in this article. See our disclosure.

Spotted a better dupe? Reply to any newsletter.