Tarte is strongest when you want an obvious makeup result: more coverage, longer-looking lashes or a glossy lip colour you can apply without a brush. Shape Tape explains the brand's appeal, but choosing the right version matters more than choosing the famous name. I would start with the original concealer for a natural matte finish, Creamy for a more moisturizing take, or Tartelette Tubing Mascara if lashes are your priority.
The range is easy to recognize and sometimes harder to shop. Shape Tape, Tartelette and Maracuja Juicy Lip are families, each with variations. A review of one member is not a review of everything carrying that name.
Tarte's appeal, beyond the purple packaging
Maureen Kelly launched Tarte with a cheek stain in 1999. The brand's timeline places its Sephora arrival in 2003, Ulta in 2010 and the original Shape Tape launch in 2016. Those dates explain why it can feel both familiar and constantly new: it builds out recognizable product families instead of starting its identity over with every launch.
Its fruit and botanical language is equally recognizable. Maracuja is passion fruit; Amazonian clay is another recurring ingredient story. Tarte defines its "high-performance naturals" positioning as a blend of naturally derived and other ingredients designed to perform. That description is more useful than reading the slogan as a promise that every formula is entirely natural.
The visual results are the selling point. A full-coverage concealer has a clear purpose. So does a glossy click-up lip colour. If you like precise, polished makeup, there are sensible starting places here. If your ideal base lets every freckle show, picking the fullest coverage simply because it is famous is less compelling.
Shape Tape: choose the finish before the shade
The original Shape Tape Concealer is US$32 for 10 ml. Tarte describes it as full coverage with a natural matte finish and positions it for normal, combination and oily skin. Its instructions recommend a small amount, dotted where needed. I would begin there, then add coverage only where it earns its place.
That approach also gives you more control over the effect. A dot on a blemish is a different job from brightening the entire undereye. The shade that makes an undereye look brighter may be conspicuous on a spot elsewhere, so choose a skin match if concealing individual marks is your main use.
Shape Tape Creamy Concealer, also US$32 for 10 ml, keeps full coverage but changes the brief to a moisturizing matte finish. Tarte positions it for normal, dry and mature skin. The current product name is Creamy; the pictured tube and older coverage also use "ultra creamy," which helps explain the naming confusion when comparing reviews.
I would look at Creamy first if you want substantial coverage but dislike a dry-looking finish. It is still a full-coverage product. Choosing the moisturizing version does not turn Shape Tape into a sheer skin tint, and adding more will not solve a poor shade match.
Tarte's shade descriptions separate depth from undertone. On the current pages, 12B is fair with cool, pink or rosy undertones; 12N is fair neutral; 12S is fair with warm, golden undertones. Use those descriptions to narrow your choice, then examine the exact formula's swatches. The most useful comparison is against your own face and neck, rather than another person's preferred brightening shade.
For readers chiefly interested in spending less, our Shape Tape concealer dupe guide addresses that different buying decision. A brand profile is the place to establish which finish you want before comparing alternatives.
Maracuja Juicy Lip: buy it for the finish you can see
Maracuja Juicy Lip Plump costs US$27 for 2.7 g. It is a glossy balm-like colour in a click-up tube, with buildable coverage. The mechanism is non-retractable: Tarte advises one click to expose the amount needed. Resist clicking up extra just to inspect the colour, because it will not wind back down like a conventional lipstick.
Its finish makes more sense to me as the reason to buy than a dramatic change in lip size. In her June 2022 Reviewed test, Sara Miranda liked the colour and softness but found the visible plumping modest. She also reported a prickling sensation and found Primrose and Mixed Berries surprisingly similar on her lips. That was her experience with those versions and shades, rather than proof of how every current colour will wear.
The current shade list describes Primrose as rosy pink and Mixed Berries as mauve berry. Those names suggest a difference, but your natural lip colour still belongs in the decision. I would choose one shade first, especially if your usual lipstick is already close to both. A glossy finish can be the change you want without needing several near-neighbours.
The Maracuja name appears across lip oils, glosses and other products too. Check the complete name when following a recommendation. The texture of Juicy Lip Plump is the relevant attraction here; a testimonial about a lip stain will not tell you whether you like this click-up formula.
Tartelette mascara: original versus XL
The original Tartelette Tubing Mascara is US$28 for 8 ml. Tarte describes a formula that forms tubes around lashes. Its application advice is specific: work on one eye at a time and apply another coat while the first is still wet.
That instruction matters if you tend to alternate between eyes and return for more volume after everything has dried. I would follow the intended application method before deciding the formula cannot build. Black is the straightforward starting shade; the current range also lists brown and colours including navy and emerald green.
There are separate original and XL versions. In Allure's April 2026 Tarte guide, Sarah Hoffmann praised XL's combination of length and volume, while Elizabeth Gulino's accompanying account specifically favoured the original for length without clumping. The distinction is useful: decide which effect appeals to you, then make sure the tube in your basket matches the review.
I would start with the original for defined everyday lashes. XL is the version to investigate if greater volume is the aim. Neither choice requires buying a concealer or lip product at the same time; mascara is a useful way into Tarte if the complexion range does not answer a problem in your routine.
What Tarte costs in the US
Regular one-time prices checked on Tarte's US pages on 20 October 2026. These are full sizes, before taxes, shipping, subscription discounts or temporary promotions.
| Product |
Full size |
US price |
| Original Shape Tape Concealer |
10 ml |
$32 |
| Shape Tape Creamy Concealer |
10 ml |
$32 |
| Maracuja Juicy Lip Plump |
2.7 g |
$27 |
| Original Tartelette Tubing Mascara |
8 ml |
$28 |
The review cards below may show prices from earlier checks. Use the dated prices and sizes in this table for the current comparison.
The brand FAQ points vegan shoppers to the designation on each product page.
Those prices put a single product within reach as a deliberate makeup purchase; a whole matching routine becomes expensive quickly. Original Shape Tape, Lip Plump and the mascara total US$87 before tax. I would spend on the product that changes your result most, then keep using the other makeup you already like.
Tarte's current direct-order return policy accepts new or gently used items within 30 days of delivery, with a US$5 return handling fee deducted from refunds. Exchanges are free, final-sale products are excluded, and the policy allows one return or exchange per order. That makes shade selection worth a little patience, even when a promotion is tempting.
If you want to compare full-coverage concealers at a lower price, our e.l.f. guide explains the satin and matte Camo options.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is Tarte best known for?
Tarte is best known for its Shape Tape concealer family, alongside Tartelette mascaras and Maracuja Juicy Lip products. The recognizable families contain different formulas, so check the complete product name before buying.
What is the difference between original and Creamy Shape Tape?
Both are full-coverage concealers. Tarte describes the original as natural matte and Creamy as moisturizing matte, positioning Creamy for normal, dry and mature skin. Both cost US$32 for 10 ml on 20 October 2026.
Does Tarte offer vegan makeup?
Yes. Tarte says many of its products are vegan and labels them on the individual product pages. Check that designation on the item you want; the brand's cruelty-free description does not by itself establish a product's ingredients.
Which Tarte product should I try first?
Choose the product that serves your routine: Shape Tape for full coverage, Maracuja Juicy Lip Plump for glossy colour, or original Tartelette Tubing Mascara for defined lashes. There is no need to buy all three to decide whether the brand suits you.