Milk Hydro Grip Primer Dupes: 4 Cheaper Options
The verdict
I’d start with e.l.f. Power Grip Primer if you want a cheaper alternative to Milk Hydro Grip. Essence Jelly Grip is the lowest-priced option here; Maybelline Grippy Serum is worth a look if you want a simpler ingredient list without the menthol in e.l.f. The qualification: we have historical comparisons of Milk and e.l.f., but no current, controlled wear test establishing that any of these lasts as long as Milk.
The first pairing I would investigate, supported by an attributed historical comparison. Current equal wear has not been established.
Read the comparison ↓US$5.99 for 0.98 fl oz is the lowest bottle and unit price in this shortlist.
Read the comparison ↓Save up to 84%the original is $38.00 — the dupes here start at $5.99
The caveat. These are research-based choices, not a current controlled wear ranking. Bottle sizes differ, so the saving shown above is the difference at checkout, not a same-volume saving.
Key takeaways
- Start with original green e.l.f. Power Grip if you want a lower-cost comparison for Milk.
- Essence is the least expensive; its ingredient list includes fragrance.
- Maybelline has 2% niacinamide and no menthol or peppermint water in the retrieved US list.
- Use the instructions for each primer: Milk says 60 seconds, e.l.f. 30 and Maybelline 20.
At a glance
| Product | Price | Size | Price/oz | Role |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Milk Makeup Hydro Grip Hydrating Primer | $38.00 | 45ml / 1.52 fl oz | $25.00/oz | Original |
| e.l.f. Cosmetics Power Grip Primer | $11.00 | 24ml / 0.8 fl oz | $13.75/oz | First comparison to try |
| NYX Professional Makeup The Face Glue Gripping Primer | $9.00 | 1.18 fl oz | $7.63/oz | Lower unit cost |
| Maybelline Grippy Serum Primer | $12.99 | 1 fl oz | $12.99/oz | Serum format |
| Essence Jelly Grip Hydrating Primer | $5.99 | 0.98 fl oz | $6.11/oz | Lowest bottle price |
Prices and sizes checked November 3, 2026.
How we compared
We checked current US listings, available ingredient lists and application directions, then read an editorial comparison and a small sample of community reports. “Dupe” here means an alternative for the same hydrating, gripping step. We did not conduct a split-face test, measure foundation wear or verify that any formula duplicates Milk’s.
US one-time prices checked 3 November 2026, excluding tax, shipping and subscriptions. Primer unit prices use the rounded US fluid-ounce declarations.
Evidence labels describe the support for this pairing, not a product score. No personal wear or laboratory testing is implied.
If you are also changing the final step of your base routine, compare the Urban Decay All Nighter alternatives.
This guide concerns the original green e.l.f. Power Grip. Its recommendation should not automatically be transferred to every product using the Power Grip name. Likewise, an illuminating base or a pore-blurring primer needs a separate comparison: the question here is grip beneath foundation.
Community reports are useful for deciding what to check, but not for certifying a formula match. In one older r/Sephora discussion, several commenters preferred e.l.f.’s packaging or found the products similar. That small, self-selected sample does not establish current wear performance.
Before replacing a primer that already works, try the candidate with your usual skincare and foundation. Check whether it pills during application and whether your foundation separates later. A successful comparison under somebody else’s base is only a starting point for yours.
e.l.f. Cosmetics Power Grip Primer
There is more than a colour resemblance behind this pairing. In PureWow’s 2022 comparison, Matthew described e.l.f. as thicker and stickier than Milk. That is useful historical evidence about feel, although it cannot establish the behaviour of every current batch. PureWow’s comparison.
The current original green e.l.f. formula lists glycerin, niacinamide and sodium hyaluronate. It also lists menthol and peppermint water. I would check those details before buying if they are ingredients you already avoid. e.l.f. says to pat it on and allow 30 seconds before makeup; Milk specifies 60 seconds. Follow the instructions for the bottle you own instead of treating the products as interchangeable. e.l.f. directions and ingredients, Milk directions.
The US$11 price is for 24ml. Milk’s US$38 bottle holds 45ml, so the saving per bottle overstates the saving per amount of product. e.l.f. still costs less by volume, but it is not a same-size replacement.
What matches
- Same hydrating, gripping step beneath foundation.
- A published comparison supports investigating the pairing.
What doesn't
- 24ml rather than Milk’s 45ml; current wear equality is unverified.
Pick it if You want a lower-cost gripping primer and do not avoid its menthol or aromatic plant waters.
The catch. The historical reviewer found it thicker and stickier; today’s 24ml bottle also contains less than Milk’s full size.
NYX Professional Makeup The Face Glue Gripping Primer
NYX’s US ingredient list includes glycerin and PVP, a film-forming polymer. That gives it a specific reason to sit in a gripping-primer comparison. The retrieved US list does not include niacinamide. I would consider it if that ingredient already features heavily in the rest of your routine, without assuming that its absence guarantees better tolerance. NYX’s US product listing.
Its US$9 bottle is larger than the regular e.l.f. bottle. That makes NYX an appealing purchase on price, but price does not settle which will work under your particular foundation. The brand’s wear-time claim is not a shared test against Milk’s claim, so I would not rank them by the hours on the packaging.
What matches
- Gripping-primer format with glycerin and film-forming PVP.
What doesn't
- No niacinamide appears in the retrieved US list; the UK list differs.
Pick it if You want a US$9 primer with a lower unit cost than the regular e.l.f. bottle.
The catch. We have no shared wear test against Milk, and the US ingredient details should not be transferred to UK stock.
Maybelline Grippy Serum Primer
Maybelline lists 2% niacinamide and directs you to give the serum 20 seconds to become tacky. Its published US list has neither menthol nor peppermint water. Those are checkable differences from the original e.l.f. formula, rather than a promise that one will suit sensitive skin better. Maybelline’s formula and directions.
This is my alternative for someone interested in a serum format who has already ruled out e.l.f.’s ingredients. It costs more than NYX and Essence. I would not pay that difference solely to add another niacinamide product beneath a routine that already has one.
What matches
- Hydrating grip beneath makeup; niacinamide is disclosed at 2%.
What doesn't
- Its published US list has neither menthol nor peppermint water.
Pick it if You prefer a serum format and have ruled out the original e.l.f. ingredients.
The catch. It costs more than NYX and Essence; another niacinamide product may add little to your existing routine.
Essence Jelly Grip Hydrating Primer
Essence combines glycerin and PVP in a US$5.99 primer. Its ingredient list also includes parfum. The low price makes it the least expensive purchase here, but someone looking specifically for a fragrance-free product should choose differently. Essence’s retailer listing and ingredients.
I would choose it on a strict spending limit, with modest expectations about how much a primer can change an existing foundation routine. There is not enough comparative evidence in this research to call it the closest match for Milk’s feel or wear.
What matches
- Glycerin and PVP in a gripping-primer format.
What doesn't
- Parfum is listed; a current head-to-head wear result is unavailable.
Pick it if Your priority is the smallest spend on a gripping primer.
The catch. The formula contains fragrance, so it does not fit a fragrance-free shopping brief.
FAQs
Is e.l.f. Power Grip identical to Milk Hydro Grip?
No. A historical reviewer found e.l.f. thicker and stickier, and this research does not establish that current formulas wear equally.
How long should primer set before foundation?
Follow the specific product directions: Milk says 60 seconds, original e.l.f. Power Grip 30 seconds and Maybelline Grippy Serum 20 seconds.
Which primer here costs the least?
Essence Jelly Grip was US$5.99 for 0.98 fl oz when checked on 3 November 2026. It has the lowest bottle and unit price in this shortlist.
Does original e.l.f. Power Grip contain menthol?
Yes. The retrieved US list includes menthol and peppermint water. Check the current package if these are ingredients you avoid.
Sources
- https://milkmakeup.com/products/hydro-grip-hydrating-face-primer
- https://www.elfcosmetics.com/products/power-grip-primer?Size=Regular+0.8+oz+%2F+24+ml
- https://www.ulta.com/p/face-glue-gripping-primer-pimprod2047574
- https://www.ulta.com/p/grippy-serum-hydrating-grip-primer-makeup-pimprod2050127
- https://www.ulta.com/p/jelly-grip-hydrating-primer-pimprod2045823?sku=2625436
- https://www.purewow.com/beauty/what-the-dupe-primer-elf-milk
- https://www.nyxcosmetics.com/face/primer/the-face-glue-gripping-primer/800897266189.html
- https://www.maybelline.com/face-makeup/primer/grippy-serum-primer
- https://www.reddit.com/r/Sephora/comments/12iv8v2/milk_hydro_grip_compared_to_elf_power_grip/
- https://www.target.com/p/-/A-94740469
More dupe guides
More from Milk Makeup.
Insider Beauty may earn a commission on purchases made through links in this article. See our disclosure.
Spotted a better dupe? Reply to any newsletter.