Best hair Products
Published Key takeaways
- Our top pick is the e.l.f. Cosmetics 3-in-Wonder Magic Styling Cream at $9 because it combines flexible hold with stated 450°F heat protection.
- Best budget option is the OGX Locking + Coconut Curls Air Dry Cream at $8.39, or $1.40 per ounce.
- Not Your Mother's is the stronger choice for humid conditions because its polymer blend is designed to improve smoothing and humidity resistance.
- Start with clarifying shampoo for ordinary buildup, and reserve the $78 Highbrow Hippie scalp scrub for stubborn residue on a non-irritated scalp.
Insider Beauty may earn a commission on purchases made through links in this article. See our disclosure.
The best hair products in this group cover very different needs, from heat styling and curl definition to scalp buildup and excess oil. I evaluated all seven by formula, intended use, price, and how clearly each brand supports its claims, rather than pretending a glitter stick and a clarifying shampoo can be judged by the same standard. My top pick is the e.l.f. Cosmetics 3-in-Wonder Magic Styling Cream because its $9 price, flexible styling polymers, and stated 450°F heat protection make it the most useful option for the most people.
How we chose the best hair products
I reviewed the ingredient information, sizes, prices, and product claims supplied for each formula. Styling products received credit for practical features such as heat protection, humidity resistance, hold, conditioning ingredients, and a reasonable cost per ounce. Scalp treatments were assessed by the type of buildup they target and whether their price makes sense for occasional use.
This wasn't a hands-on consumer panel, and no retailer ratings or review counts were included in the source data. I won't invent them. Each review below clearly identifies that limitation, since a missing rating is different from a poor rating.
The final ranking reflects broad usefulness first, followed by ingredient transparency and value. Specialized products can still be the right purchase, but a $78 scalp scrub has a much narrower audience than a $9 styling cream.
e.l.f. Cosmetics 3-in-Wonder Magic Styling Cream
Price: $9 for 5 oz
Price per ounce: $1.80
Best for: Heat styling, soft hold, blowout preparation, and basic curl definition
Not ideal for: People seeking an oil-rich curl cream or very strong hold
I keep coming back to this one because the formula is unusually practical for $9. The 3-in-Wonder Magic Styling Cream is designed to prepare hair for a blowout, define curls, and provide flexible hold. It also claims heat protection up to 450°F, which gives it a meaningful advantage over the similarly priced OGX curl cream.
The ingredient order supports at least part of the styling story. Water is followed by cetearyl alcohol, glycerin, and neopentyl glycol diheptanoate. Cetearyl alcohol is a fatty alcohol, not the drying type of alcohol people often worry about, and it helps give a cream slip and softness. Glycerin is a humectant, although its performance can vary with climate and the rest of the formula.
VP/VA copolymer appears fifth. That's a film-forming styling polymer commonly used to create hold. Propanediol follows in sixth place, while creatine and hydrolyzed pea and vegetable proteins provide a protein-focused alternative to plant oils. Proteins can temporarily improve the feel of porous or damaged hair, but hair that's easily stiffened by protein may need a lighter application.
There are no plant oils in the disclosed formula. I don't see that as an automatic drawback. Fine hair and straighter textures often do better with a cream that doesn't deposit a heavy blend of oils and butters. Very dry, coarse curls may want more lubrication.
At $1.80 per ounce, this is the second-lowest cost per ounce among the products with enough size information to calculate it. Use a small amount through damp mid-lengths and ends before blow-drying. For curls, scrunch it into wet hair and let it dry without repeatedly touching it.
Rating context: No star rating or review count was provided. Its first-place ranking is based on the disclosed formula, versatility, heat-protection claim, and price rather than retailer review volume.
Not Your Mother's All Eyes On Me 3-in-1 Styling Cream
Price: $9.99 for 5.5 oz
Price per ounce: $1.82
Best for: Frizz-prone hair, humid conditions, blow-drying, and air-drying
Not ideal for: Very fine hair that becomes oily or limp with multiple emollients
The All Eyes On Me 3-in-1 Styling Cream misses first place by a very small margin. Honestly, its formula may be the more interesting of the two leading styling creams if humidity is your main complaint. It costs $9.99, just 99 cents more than the e.l.f. cream, and the cost per ounce is nearly identical at $1.82.
This silicone-free formula is sold as a blow-dry primer, air-dry cream, and smoothing styler. It claims both 450°F heat protection and UV protection. Heat protection is useful if you regularly use a dryer or hot tools, although I still recommend keeping tool temperatures as low as your hair allows. UV protection claims for hair are harder for a shopper to verify, and they shouldn't be confused with scalp sunscreen.
VP/VA copolymer provides film formation and hold. Polyester-11 and capryloyl glycerin/sebacic acid copolymer add further support for smoothing and humidity resistance. That combination is why I rank this above simpler creams for people who live in damp climates.
The conditioning side includes chia and linseed extracts, ethyl macadamiate, argan oil, and squalane. Ethyl macadamiate is a lightweight emollient derived from macadamia, while squalane can help reduce a rough or dry feel without behaving exactly like a heavy plant butter. Still, this is a richer ingredient profile than the e.l.f. cream. Start with less than you think you need if your hair is fine.
The difference between $1.80 and $1.82 per ounce is negligible. Choose this over the top pick if frizz control and humidity resistance matter more to you than avoiding oils. Apply it from the ears down before blow-drying, especially if your scalp gets oily.
Rating context: The supplied data doesn't include a star rating or review count. The second-place position reflects the formula and value, not an undisclosed customer score.
OGX Locking + Coconut Curls Air Dry Cream
Price: $8.39 for 6 oz
Price per ounce: $1.40
Best for: Air-dried curls, budget shoppers, and people who like coconut-scented products
Not ideal for: Heat styling, fragrance-sensitive users, or hair that is easily weighed down by coconut oil and shea butter
At $1.40 per ounce, the OGX Locking + Coconut Curls Air Dry Cream is the least expensive product per ounce among the three items with listed sizes. It also has the largest listed container at 6 ounces. If you want an affordable air-dry cream for curls and have no need for heat protection, this is the clear value pick.
The 16-ingredient formula takes a different approach from the two creams above it. Tapioca starch is second, polyquaternium-37 is fourth, and PVM/MA copolymer is tenth. Tapioca starch can absorb some oil and alter texture, while the polymers help with film formation and curl control.
Coconut oil appears fifth and shea butter sixth. Those ingredients can improve softness and reduce a dry feel in coarse, dense, or porous curls. They can also leave fine waves looking flat if too much is applied. Coconut oil doesn't work equally well for everyone, and some people find that frequent use makes their hair feel rigid rather than supple.
There is no cetearyl alcohol, behentrimonium chloride, VP/VA copolymer, or dimethicone in the provided ingredient summary. More significantly, the product makes no stated heat-protection claim. I would use it for air-drying as directed, not as the sole protectant before a flat iron or curling iron.
The coconut scent is another deciding factor. Fragrance in a hair product isn't inherently harmful for most users, but it can be irritating if it contacts an eczema-prone or fragrance-allergic scalp. Keep it on the lengths if your scalp is reactive.
Rating context: No rating or review count was supplied. Its third-place ranking comes from its low price, curl-focused composition, and strong cost per ounce, with points deducted for its limited use around heat.
Bumble and bumble Seaweed Oil Control Styling Primer
Price: $36
Size and price per ounce: Not provided
Best for: Oily scalps paired with fine strands
Not ideal for: Very dry scalps, coarse hair that needs richer conditioning, or shoppers focused primarily on price
The Seaweed Oil Control Styling Primer is the most targeted daily styling option here. It's designed for people who have an oily scalp but fine hair that collapses under rich creams. That combination can be frustrating because aggressively stripping the scalp may leave the hair rough without providing reliable long-term oil control.
The source says this primer helps control excess oil without weighing hair down. That makes sense as a product concept, but the full ingredient list wasn't provided, so I can't assess which absorbent or film-forming ingredients are doing the work. The name references seaweed, yet a product name alone doesn't tell us the extract concentration or clinical significance.
At $36, it costs four times as much as the $9 e.l.f. styling cream. The missing size also prevents a fair price-per-ounce calculation. I have mixed feelings about ranking it this high without that information, but it addresses a specific need that the richer creams may aggravate.
Use it primarily near the roots and follow with a separate product on dry ends if needed. Oil-control products can improve the appearance of greasy roots, but they don't permanently alter sebaceous gland activity. Sudden or severe scalp oiliness accompanied by redness, scale, or itching deserves a dermatology evaluation.
Rating context: No customer rating or review count was included. Its ranking is based on its suitability for oily scalps and fine hair, with the $36 price and missing size limiting the value assessment.
Chris McMillan The Clarifying Shampoo
Price: $38
Size and price per ounce: Not provided
Best for: Product buildup, frequent dry-shampoo use, and hair that feels coated
Not ideal for: Daily washing, very dry curls, or an actively irritated scalp
A clarifying shampoo can make a visible difference when conditioners, styling polymers, oils, or dry shampoo have accumulated on the hair. Chris McMillan's The Clarifying Shampoo costs $38 and is described as a detox formula that resets the scalp and hair by removing buildup, stimulating the scalp, and balancing oil production.
Of those claims, buildup removal is the one I find most straightforward. Shampoo surfactants can remove deposited oils and styling residue. Claims about stimulating the scalp or balancing oil production are less clear without a full ingredient list or supporting study. Cleansing can make a scalp feel fresher, but it doesn't necessarily retrain oil glands.
The source doesn't provide the bottle size, surfactant system, or chelating ingredients. That's a meaningful gap at this price. Hard-water buildup, for example, may respond best to a shampoo containing a chelator, while ordinary styling buildup may only require effective surfactants.
Use a clarifying shampoo occasionally rather than automatically making it your daily cleanser. Once every one to four weeks is a reasonable starting range, depending on oil production, product use, and hair texture. Follow it with conditioner on the lengths. Color-treated hair should be monitored for fading and dryness.
Rating context: No rating or review count was provided. I ranked it fifth because clarifying is useful, but the absent size and ingredient details make its $38 value difficult to judge.
Highbrow Hippie Triple-Action Revitalizing Enzyme Scrub
Price: $78
Size and price per ounce: Not provided
Best for: Persistent scalp buildup and shoppers who specifically want a premium exfoliating treatment
Not ideal for: Sensitive, inflamed, scratched, or recently chemically treated scalps
At $78, the Triple-Action Revitalizing Enzyme Scrub is the most expensive product in the ranking. It uses physical and chemical exfoliation plus chelation to remove buildup, then includes ceramides to support hydration. On paper, that's a thoughtful approach for residue that includes dead skin, styling deposits, and hard-water minerals.
Chelation is particularly relevant if you have mineral-heavy water. Chemical exfoliation can loosen superficial buildup, while physical particles provide immediate scrubbing. That layered approach also raises the potential for overuse. More exfoliation isn't always better, especially on a scalp with seborrheic dermatitis, psoriasis, folliculitis, or open areas from scratching.
Ceramides are useful lipids in skin-barrier care, although their presence doesn't cancel out irritation caused by aggressive scrubbing. Use light pressure and follow the package frequency. Stop if you develop burning, persistent redness, tenderness, or increased flaking.
The research behind scalp exfoliation for routine hair growth or oil control is thin. This product may help the scalp feel cleaner, but shoppers shouldn't assume that a $78 scrub treats medical hair loss. I would reserve it for someone who knows they enjoy scalp exfoliants and has stubborn buildup that ordinary clarifying shampoo hasn't addressed.
Rating context: No star rating or review count was given. The price, missing size, and narrow use case place it sixth despite its more elaborate exfoliation system.
E.l.f. Hair Shimmer Glimmer Glitter Hair Stick
Price: $8
Size and price per ounce: Not provided
Best for: Decorative slick-backs, parties, concerts, and temporary sparkle
Not ideal for: Heat protection, conditioning, scalp care, or everyday frizz control
The Shimmer Glimmer Glitter Hair Stick is the cheapest product by total purchase price at $8, but it's also the most specialized. It's intended to give slicked-back styles a festive finish. That's fun and specific. It isn't a substitute for any of the functional styling creams or scalp products ranked above it.
A stick format should make targeted application easier around a bun, ponytail, or part. It may also be less messy than loose glitter. The supplied description doesn't include the size, ingredient list, hold level, or removal instructions, so I can't calculate value by ounce or assess how well it suits sensitive scalps.
Cosmetic glitter products should be used as directed and kept away from the eyes unless they are explicitly labeled for eye-area use. Shampoo the product out rather than scratching or picking particles from the scalp. If you're prone to contact dermatitis, test a small area before covering a full part line.
Buy this for visible sparkle, not hair care. Its seventh-place position reflects limited versatility rather than poor performance.
Rating context: The source provides no rating or review count. There isn't enough information to compare customer satisfaction with the other six products.
Hair product price comparison
| Rank | Product | Price | Size | Price per oz | Main use |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | e.l.f. Cosmetics 3-in-Wonder Magic Styling Cream | $9.00 | 5 oz | $1.80 | Heat styling and flexible hold |
| 2 | Not Your Mother's All Eyes On Me 3-in-1 Styling Cream | $9.99 | 5.5 oz | $1.82 | Humidity-resistant styling |
| 3 | OGX Locking + Coconut Curls Air Dry Cream | $8.39 | 6 oz | $1.40 | Air-dried curls |
| 4 | Bumble and bumble Seaweed Oil Control Styling Primer | $36.00 | Not provided | Not calculable | Oily scalp and fine hair |
| 5 | Chris McMillan The Clarifying Shampoo | $38.00 | Not provided | Not calculable | Buildup removal |
| 6 | Highbrow Hippie Triple-Action Revitalizing Enzyme Scrub | $78.00 | Not provided | Not calculable | Scalp exfoliation and chelation |
| 7 | E.l.f. Hair Shimmer Glimmer Glitter Hair Stick | $8.00 | Not provided | Not calculable | Decorative sparkle |
The E.l.f. Hair glitter stick has the lowest upfront price at $8, while the Highbrow Hippie scrub is the most expensive at $78. Among products with listed sizes, OGX is the cheapest by volume at $1.40 per ounce. The two leading styling creams are nearly tied at $1.80 and $1.82 per ounce.
A low total price doesn't always mean better value. Without sizes for four products, any price-per-ounce comparison involving them would be speculation.
How to choose the right hair product
The best hair products are the ones matched to how you style your hair and what your scalp actually needs. Use this process before buying:
- Decide whether you're treating the scalp or styling the hair. A clarifying shampoo removes residue, while a cream changes hold, softness, or definition. One can't reliably replace the other.
- Match the formula to your strand thickness. Fine hair is more likely to be weighed down by coconut oil, shea butter, or several emollients. Coarse and porous hair may appreciate that richness.
- Check for stated heat protection. The e.l.f. Cosmetics and Not Your Mother's creams claim protection up to 450°F. OGX doesn't make a stated heat-protection claim in the supplied information.
- Consider your climate. For high humidity, I prefer the polymer blend in the Not Your Mother's cream. In a dry climate, monitor humectant-rich products for how they make your hair feel rather than assuming glycerin will always behave the same way.
- Treat scalp exfoliation cautiously. A scrub can remove buildup, but burning and persistent redness aren't signs that it is working better. People with diagnosed scalp conditions should ask a dermatologist before adding physical exfoliation.
- Compare cost by volume where possible. OGX offers the lowest known cost per ounce. Missing size information makes the premium scalp and cleansing products harder to assess fairly.
Frequently asked questions
Which product is best for blow-drying?
The e.l.f. Cosmetics 3-in-Wonder Magic Styling Cream is my first choice for most blowouts because it costs $9, contains a film-forming hold polymer, and claims 450°F heat protection. Choose Not Your Mother's instead if humidity resistance is the bigger priority.
Which product is best for curls?
OGX is the most curl-specific and affordable at $8.39 for 6 ounces, or $1.40 per ounce. It contains coconut oil and shea butter, so it is better suited to curls that tolerate richer ingredients. Use the e.l.f. cream if you want lighter conditioning or plan to diffuse with heat.
Do I need both a clarifying shampoo and a scalp scrub?
Usually, no. Start with a clarifying shampoo if your issue is styling residue or oil. Consider the Highbrow Hippie scrub only if you want physical and chemical exfoliation plus chelation, and your scalp isn't inflamed or sensitive.
Which option should I buy first?
For general styling, buy the e.l.f. Cosmetics 3-in-Wonder Magic Styling Cream. Choose OGX for air-dried curls on a tighter budget, or Not Your Mother's if frizz in humid weather is your main concern.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should I choose the e.l.f. Cosmetics or Not Your Mother's styling cream?
Choose the $9 e.l.f. cream for versatile styling, lighter conditioning, and stated 450°F heat protection. Choose the $9.99 Not Your Mother's cream if humidity resistance and richer emollients are higher priorities.
Which product is best for air-dried curls?
OGX Locking + Coconut Curls Air Dry Cream is the most curl-focused air-dry option. It costs $8.39 for 6 ounces, but its coconut oil, shea butter, and coconut scent may not suit fine or fragrance-sensitive hair.
Can a scalp scrub replace clarifying shampoo?
Not necessarily. Clarifying shampoo is the better first step for oil and styling residue. The Highbrow Hippie scrub adds physical and chemical exfoliation plus chelation, but it costs $78 and may be too aggressive for a sensitive or inflamed scalp.